« Kahle v. Gonzales: a review and a request | Main | Internet Policy: What Congress Should Do »

Fox News gets "fair use" religion

You'll remember Roger Ailes' view of Robert Greenwald's film, Outfoxed. As reported in 2004, Ailes said:

Any news organization that doesn’t support our position on copyright is crazy. Next week, we could take a month’s worth of video from CNN International and do a documentary “Why does CNN hate America?” You wouldn’t even have to do the hatchet job Outfoxed was. You damn well could run it without editing. CNN International, Al-Jazeera and BBC are the same in how they report-mostly that America is wrong and bad. Everybody should stand up and say these people don’t have the right to take our product anymore. They don’t have a right to take a year’s worth of Dan Rather or Ted Koppel and edit it any way they want. It puts journalism at risk.

Well, it seems Fox has now gotten religion. According to this LA Times report, Sean Hannity will air excerpts that had been removed from ABC's controversial "Path to 9/11." The excerpts "depict then-national security advisor Samuel R. "Sandy" Berger refusing to approve a CIA request to attack Osama bin Laden" - an event Berger said never happened.

I can understand Fox's "fair use" argument — though of course its tougher with work that's not been published. But it's really good to see that Fox now understands the importance of "fair use."

| | technorati

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://lessig.org/mt/mt-tb.cgi/2008

Comments (17)

where you want to find good life ,of course in the games .because in the real life ,we have many distresses and pain only in the games if we have enough gold to buy the good arms ,and we can play the games well.so i'll give u one website low price and excellent service for you ! Here we sell game CD key and game card ,include Ever Quest2(Gold Plat) ,Final FantasyⅪ(Gil),Guild Wars(Gold),RF online(CP) ,star wars Galaxies(credit),Anarchy online(credit),Auto Assault (scrip),City of Villains (Infarmy)D&D online(PP),Eve online, EQ(plat),Lineage2(adena),Maple story,Matrix online ,WOW(gold). www.igfire.com igfire-sales@hotmail.com

I'm sure it's only out of convenience that they recognize fair use.

Supposing Outfoxed weren't a hatchet job? (Is it really?) Even if it were, suppose someone else manages to make a better, non-hatchet documentary of Fox's bias. How would Fox feel about fair use *then*?

Nice ideas, needed to be said

Well what do you expect from the only Fair and Balanced news channel on cable? Of course they understand Fair Use!

January 27, 2007 9:04 AM three blind mice:

with Fox News (and Sean Hannity) as friends, who needs enemies?

The shocking thing is that Fox et al. are so convinced that information only has a commercial life, that it is merely an investment vehicle to be exploited to the maximum; there is a wholesale denial of the fact that the media environment should be the subject of interrogation and criticism. I wouldn't count on the fact that they are now invoking fair use as a promise that they'll change the approach to their own content in the future.

The last couple of years have seen too many shrill claims about fair use for my liking - as if it's become a bucket into which to pour complaints arising from proprietary colonization occuring elsewhere (term extension, DMCA etc) - but cases such as Outfoxed fall so clearly within the exception that any attempt to prevent them should be the basis for counter claim. Hit the bully on the nose!


http://knowfuture.wordpress.com

You seem to be having some character-set issues; the original posting (at least in my Mozilla SeaMonkey browser) shows some garbage where things like quotes and apostrophes should be, apparently as a result of pasting in UTF-8 characters in a page that's being sent as iso-8859-1.

Great post!

All the news companies filter what they play.

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Congratulations! really great work thanks!
All the Best for further challenges!

Post a comment

By entering the words in the box, you are also helping to digitize texts that were written before the computer age. The words that you see were taken directly from old texts that are being scanned and stored by the Internet Archive. This CAPTCHA helps proofread the books. If the sample is too hard to read, click the recycle button to get another two. A space between each word is required. And thanks for the comment and help.